Showing posts with label statistics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label statistics. Show all posts

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Uncertain Knowledge, Ontologies, and Reasoners – A Discussion of Semantic Ambiguity in the Presence of Statistical Uncertainty

Before continuing with uncertain domain knowledge, the subject of this and future posts, I’d like to give an example. I’ll introduce a scenario in which both semantic ambiguity (refer to my prior post) and statistical uncertainty (refer to the tutorials in the right-hand column of this blog) are present.

One of the limitations of most current description logic (DL) reasoners (refer to my August 6 & 24 posts below) is the inability to handle uncertain knowledge. It is a serious obstacle to the expansion of the Semantic Web, to name just one technology, because many domains of human interest contains knowledge that cannot be represented with absolute certainty. One example of an uncertain domain is medicine, in particular, disease diagnosis. Symptoms, causes and consequences of many diseases are uncertain which complicates conceptualization of such domains in formal ontologies and thus restricts machine understanding.

The next two figures, rendered without further explanation, illustrate that the difficulties introduced by semantic ambiguity of a deterministic kind can be made even more difficult when there is a need to consider statistical uncertainty at the same time. This might be the case when a patient is seen by one doctor and then asks a second doctor for his or her opinion.


However, these days, a good deal of technology is often employed by doctors before they speak to patients and to each other.


{ click on the images above for larger views }

To be continued . . .

Monday, May 11, 2009

Social networking and search engine optimization: E-Marketing for the healthcare and related industries


This post will take a limited look at social media and search engine optimization in the context of the healthcare and related industries and how some of their entities are using these new technologies.

As we all know, social media can be used by healthcare professionals and the public to talk about a biotech company's products and brand. But biotech companies, as a general rule, have avoided social media for various reasons, including the lack of guidance from regulatory bodies like the FDA on remaining compliant while using social media approaches and difficulties measuring results, tracking popularity and audience activity.

In fact, many companies’ internal legal and regulatory teams stifle the kind of free communication social media affords because of ever-present fears of the increased scrutiny and legwork that come with associated obligations like adverse event reporting.

But there are ways to use social media tools that avoid these kinds of quagmires and stand to deliver real value to biotech companies and others. This is actually where the true beauty (flexibility) of technology is. Some entities are using indirect approaches (such as creating unbranded Facebook pages) or even emerging social media tools like Twitter for non-traditional advertising forays, such as making “announcements” about products and activities (e.g., twitter.com/boehringer and twitter.com/novartis).

Caveat Emptor

Before you launch a campaign that depends on a particular social media (or any other) application, understand it well. A case in point: currently, more than 60 percent of U.S. Twitter users fail to return the following month, or in other words, Twitter’s audience retention rate, or the percentage of a given month’s users who come back the following month, is currently about 40 percent. To be clear, a high retention rate does not guarantee a massive audience, but it is a prerequisite. There simply are not enough new users to make up for defecting ones after a certain point.

Compare Twitter to the two heavily-touted behemoths of social networking when they were just starting out. When Facebook and MySpace were emerging networks as Twitter is now, their retention rates were twice as high. Twitter has enjoyed a nice ride over the last few months, but it will not be able to sustain its meteoric rise without establishing a higher level of user loyalty.

A pharmaceutical company

Consider the pharmaceutical company Pfizer's roll out of a pan-European digital campaign encouraging people to stop smoking using social media (see why their campaign is an example of viral marketing, later in this post).

Pfizer is trying to engage its audience through the use of social media channels where their audience is (i.e. Twitter and Facebook). This makes even more sense in Europe, where smoking is probably more prevalent and more acceptable, especially among younger folk.

Traditional marketing vs. social media

IMHO (In My Humble Opinion / In My Honest Opinion), a big difference between traditional marketing and the social media used by Pfizer is that the former really doesn’t take as much effort after the launch of the campaign, other than to monitor and analyze; whereas with social media, the big effort really starts at the launch, as the tools are designed to facilitate interaction and engagement in order to develop an ongoing relationship with the customer. And like with any kind of relationship, it takes effort, empathy, and regular communication in order for it to blossom and grow. A one time effort with no continuing engagement will lose the interest of the social media audience very quickly, especially if it’s just marketing/advertising in disguise.

An entire community

Social networks helped cause the FDA to rescind the ban on concentrated morphine:

The FDA demanded that the production of concentrated liquid morphine be stopped. Nine days later, they changed their mind and rescinded the decision. It's amazing that the FDA reversed course in what seemed to be record time. The entire palliative care community, including their organizations, physicians, patients and families presented a united front of dissent, which helped persuade the FDA. They used social networks, like blogs, Twitter and Facebook to rapidly spread the message as well as the ramifications surrounding the announcement.

Search engine optimization et al

E-marketing techniques such as search engine optimization (SEO), analytics and content monitoring offer organizations control over website content and promotion, while at the same time allowing them to use social media merely as a pointer to their website -- the more traditional source of information. In contrast to the activities at social networking sites, activity at these destination websites can actually be measured, categorised ... and all sorts of other nice things that marketing managers, analysts and executives like to do!

So, the general idea is to make your own sites (the entity, service, product or others you may have) the central information storage area. Whatever you want to promote, either directly or indirectly, lives there (where regulatory uncertainties are less daunting). But, of course, you have to ensure that all your content is of interest to the audience you're targeting and to search engines.

So, first you need to search engine optimize your content. This entails activities such as:


* finding out exactly what you want to promote
* compiling a list of keywords and phrases you want to use for that
* exploring the popularity of such keywords and identifying others which may be relevant but you are not using
* establishing a final list of keywords to be used
* ensuring that your website content contains the above keywords

Doing so will help you write and expose information which is in demand, in line with what you want to promote and that the public and healthcare professionals can easily find online. For an easy-to-read guide to SEO practices, see "Search Engine Optimization" by Rebecca Lieb (2009).

Next, ensure that your search engine optimized website can now track visitors and their actions: what they see, where they go, what they click on and the path they follow. This is where analytics come in. You’ll want to analyze your Web server logs or utilize third party tools such as Google Analytics to measure any activity on your website. Being aware of and understanding this activity can provide invaluable information, including market trends, personal preferences, regional/organisational statistics and a lot more.

Controlling the message

You’re now ready to turn to social media. Social media tools can now be used without hesitation when they are used to point to traditional and existing information already on your site, rather than to talk about your subject matter or organization in an open and uncontrolled forum.

So, for instance, if your website contains a wealth of well-exposed information related to a specific therapy area, people will find it and could start talking on social media about it as an information resource. This in turn will lead to more traffic to your site, from both healthcare professionals and the public, which can be measured, analyzed and classified according to your needs.

The proof is in the pudding

If you have a well optimized website, visitors to your site will spend more time there and tend to return. You can measure these parameters before and after optimization, using tools like Google Analytics to determine the extent of this success.

The general idea, therefore, is to use good, search engine optimized content to attract attention, analytics to measure it and social media as an extra channel for directing people to your site. Country-specific challenges remain, however.

Regulations in some countries, ABPI guidelines in the UK for example, may interpret this use of social media as promotional and hold you responsible for any links leading to your site, regardless of whether they are informational/educational or truly promotional. However, the fact is that even without social media being used as an extra communications channel, nothing spreads the word about your sevices, products or other content better than a well developed and SEO optimized site.

Viral marketing

Some call the practice of “re-directing” people to your website “viral marketing” instead of social media. Viral marketing facilitates and encourages people to pass along a marketing message.

Postscript I: Social networking at hospitals and other healthcare organizations

Hospitals can (and are) using social media to achieve certain of their goals. Ed Bennett of the University of Maryland has put together a very comprehensive list of social networking sites hosted by hospitals including their use of Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. YouTube looks like the most common but many are moving forward with Twitter. Some have clearer strategies with Twitter and other Web 2.0 tools than others. Most are using Twitter for health advice, others as an abbreviated version of press releases. It remains to be seen where this will go in the future - how it might be used in emergency communication or employee communication.

At the time of this posting, Mayo Clinic has about 5000 fans on its Facebook page -- interesting posts from patients, family members, and physicians. Its Facebook site includes information on the Clinic, links to various web sites, videos, and more. But, most important, it has "The Wall" -- that empty page where you can write your thoughts, wishes, and other posts.

St. Jude's Hospital has over 25,000 fans and it appears that there are many hospitals on Facebook that have created their own pages. By comparison, Target stores has 173,000 fans, Starbucks has 987,000 fans, and Nike has over 1.1 million registered fans, to name just a few in the "power brands" category.

Postscript II: Website optimization

The relatively new field of website optimization (not to be confused with the search engine optimization discussed above) uses specialties such as statistics, user experience testing, and cognitive psychology to get visitors to convert (i.e., do what you want them to do, once they've landed on your site). I talk about this topics in my recent article Statistical and Financial Considerations in Website Optimization. There's a link to it at in my selected bibliography at the bottom of this blog, for anyone who's interested.



Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Electronic Health Records (EHR)

The health information technology provisions in the Obama administration's stimulus bill are a step toward the goal of nearly universal electronic health record adoption in the U.S. over the next 10 years (compared with 17 percent today). The central feature of the plan is incentive payments for using electronic records for improvements in health quality, efficiency, prevention and safety.

This kind of spending, if done wrong, can have the negative market consequence of interfering with rapid innovation by locking in today’s processes and technologies, which although well-intended, came about without a systemic view. And we risk locking out the very innovations we need for meaningful health information sharing to support better decisions.

The goal for health IT should not be primarily the creation of standards or the certification of software. Rather, standards and certification should support measurable health improvements. Health improvements are not achieved by the mere installation of software; they are achieved through the effective use of information for better decision-making.

At the same time, individual states -- for example Massachusetts, which has a newly passed law that requires hospitals and community health centers in the state to implement an electronic health record systems by Oct. 1, 2015 -- have also been moving to improve the delivery of better health care through the use of EHR.

To implement these programs, the healthcare industry seems poised to increase the adoption of EHR and electronic transmission standards to promote accuracy, transparency, and processing speed across disparate information systems. Today, they have a smorgasbord of health information technologies available to help them build a far better health system.

There are, in fact, too many standards and too many organizations writing them. There are the standards that support the systems we have in place today as well as the XML/Web-based standards that support newer web-centric systems and healthcare information exchanges.

While creating EHR data is an important first goal, an EHR is much more valuable if it can be summarized, moved, and shared. This and future posts will address EHR in that broader context. These discussions will address many technical, clinical, economic, political and managerial issues of electronic health record systems.

Perhaps the most difficult challenge is to bind the standards to structured vocabularies to ensure that there is the transfer of unambiguous knowledge of the meaning of the data among cooperating systems.

Before I get specific (sometimes talking about tools to facilitate implementation of these systems), I want to point out that building technology on U.S. standards alone would leave us with essentially a non-standard EHR platform. Remember that other countries, for example Canada and England, have single-payer health systems, while the U.S. does not.

A look back to before the PC, the Internet and all that

And, before looking ahead to how Electronic Health Records of the future will likely work, I thought I'd also display a pulmonary function test report produced at Yale New Haven Hospital (YNHH) several decades ago. While its underlying data (held in a PDP-8 computer) could be transmitted electronically -- analog modem to analog modem -- over a 128 bits/sec telephone line connection, these paper reports were generally sent from the laboratory where they were generated to the office of a YNHH physician via inter-office mail or to an outside physician via the U.S. Postal Service.



Computer-generated paper report: This photograph was produced by a Poloroid instant camera that was suspended over the front of a cathode ray tube (CRT). The CRT, along with a teletypewriter, provided human readable output for the PDP-8.

In subsequent posts, I'll include talk about safe wireless practices, Web services and other seemingly off-topic subjects, because they too are important parts of the EHR story.

Interoperability will be among these topics. The linking of vital information as patients receive care from a fragmented healthcare system is a problem that has consistently plagued interoperability efforts in healthcare. The privacy, technical, and policy issues involved need be addressed in order to effectively share information across multiple organizations. Making the information available will help to prevent drug interactions and adverse events, avoid medical errors, and help inform decision making for the patient and clinician. It will also enable the support of public health efforts, improvements in research, better physician and organizational performance and benchmarking, and greater empowerment of patients and families as active participants in their own healthcare, among other benefits.

In discussing these issues, I will sometimes cite my earlier writing on financial, legal and organizational issues that appears in articles available through links provided in my bibliography at the bottom of this page.

Finally, this might be a good time to introduce a few technical terms: HL7, HL7 mapping, HIPPA etc. They're central to the discussion of IT health records management.

Health Level 7 (HL7)

HL7 refers to both a standards organization and the set of healthcare messaging standards that it creates. Founded in 1987 to create a set of standards for hospital information systems (HIS), HL7 has expanded its reach to the creation of international standards that transgress hospitals to address clinical and administrative data in healthcare domains such as pharmaceutical, medical device, and insurance transactions. There are already a large number of countries that have mandated the use of HL7 for the transmission of healthcare data and there is an expectation that HL7 will become a part of the United State's Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) in the future.

For the large number of international healthcare organizations that are embracing the electronic transmission of healthcare data, there remain some formidable challenges. Though some compliance regulations specify the newer, XML-based HL7 v3.x, there are many jurisdictions that still need to update their legacy systems to handle this format, and many that even have multiple disparate data formats in the same system.

In the US, for example, many legacy HISs employ HL7 EDI messages alongside HIPAA X12N messages. Though these formats have quite a lot in common, syntactically speaking, they are by no means interoperable and must be mapped on-the-fly to create a dynamic workflow for managing healthcare transactions. Of course, the introduction of the XML-based HL7 v3.x adds EDI/XML mapping to the complication of mapping data from EDI to EDI.

HL7 mapping

There are off-the-shelf, any-to-any graphical data mapping tool (e.g., Altova MapForce) that supports mapping HL7 data, in its legacy EDI or newer XML-based format, to and from XML, databases, flat files, other EDI formats, and Web services. Mappings are implemented by simply importing the necessary data structures (MapForce ships with configuration files for the latest EDI standards and offers the full set of past and present HL7 standards as a free download on its Web site) and dragging lines to connect nodes. A built-in function library lets you add advanced data filters and functions to further manipulate the output data. MapForce can also facilitate the automation of your HL7 transaction workflow through code generation in Java, C#, or C++ and an accessible command line interface. Additional support for mapping HL7 data to and from Web services gives healthcare organizations the ability to meet new technology challenges and changing enterprise infrastructures as they unfold within internal and external provider domains.

Friday, April 3, 2009

Website and Supermarket Optimization {there are similarities and differences}


The relatively new field of Website optimization uses specialties such as statistics, user experience testing, and cognitive psychology to get visitors to convert (i.e., do what you want them to do, once they've landed on your site). I talk about these topics in my recent article Statistical and Financial Considerations in Website Optimization. There's a link to it at in my selected bibliography at the bottom of this blog, for anyone who's interested.

The optimization of Websites and supermarkets are both data driven tasks and both have the same goal: to capture visitor/customer activities in your Website/store and transform data about these behaviors into actionable management information.

Before getting too caught up in the art and science of Website optimization, it might be useful to pause for a moment and review some of the widely-used practices for in-store marketing and layout. As you do so, try to see the rather conspicuous parallels between what we do (as outlined in my article) and what they do (as outlined below).

But, remember that unique differences exist between how internet and brick and mortar channels can and do make money. For example, search engines like Google, Yahoo and Sphere help Website publishers to find stories by aggregating links to newspaper websites and blogs. In so doing, they wrest ad dollars from them that they think should be theirs. Not to mention the fact that, in so doing, these Websites are taking copyrighted material. Option like this are clearly not available to brick and mortar stores.

Note: The Associated Press and its member newspapers will take legal action against Web sites that use newspaper articles without legal permission, the group said recently, in a clear shot at aggregators like Google.

From a consumers point of view, a supermarket is quite simple; Put what you want into your cart and go through the check-out. Behind the scenes though, psychology is used a lot to define what products and brands you buy in supermarkets. Stands are designed to catch your eye and the store layout is structured to maximize profit.

Eye level marketing

Generally speaking, the most expensive items with high profit margins are placed on shelves that are at shoppers' eye level. Statistics show that you are more likely to see them than the less profitable brands at the very top or near your feet.

Aisle order

Some customers, particularly men, tend to simply shop for what they want, walking down an aisle grabbing what they want, turning back and walking the way they came, this is called the 'Boomerang Effect'. In order to maximize shopper and produce contact time, markets therefore place major items and brands in the middle of aisles ensuring that from any direction the customer doesn't have to walk the farthest to reach them.

Product grouping

Items that complement each other are often found close together to entice you to buy more. You'll often find pasta sauces on the same display as a featured brand of pasta.

Food smells make you feel hungry

Another tactic supermarkets use is the smell of freshly baked bread coming from the in-store bakery. The smell of warm bread makes people feel hungry. When you feel hungry while shopping you are more likely to buy additional items. Most Supermarkets bake their bread early in the morning; however, to entice more customers, some have resorted to pumping out the smell of fresh baking bread to add to the illusion that it is constantly baked through the day.

Essentials at the back

Supermarkets hit upon the idea of placing the essentials, such as bread and milk, at the back of the store. This is in order to make people have to walk past the rest of the produce, and heighten the possibility of impulse buys, in order to get their necessities. (Changing rooms in clothes stores are almost always situated at the rear of the store.)

Attracting children

One American supermarket chain came up with the idea of drawing a hopscotch in the aisle next to the children's cereal in order to make the children play and thus pin Mom & Pop to a point where the children could hassle them for treats.

Irrational Pricing

Irrational pricing is putting the price of items at say 4.99 instead of 5. The reason offered for not instead rounding $4.99 to $5.00 is based on memory processing time. Rounding upward involves an additional decision compared with storing the first digits. Furthermore, due to the vast quantity of information available for consumers to process, the information on price must be stored in a very short interval. The cheapest way to do so, in memory and attention terms, is by storing the first digits. Therefore customers perceive to be getting a better deal than they in fact are.

Point Of Sale

While you are waiting to pay, retailers often install Point Of Sale displays, this is especially prevalent in Supermarkets who install racks of chocolate to tempt bored children waiting with their parents.

Shuffle and Time

Many stores have a policy of regularly rotating the stock. This happens especially in supermarkets where people regularly shop for the same items. The idea obviously is to confront customers with a variety of items aside from their regulars and encourage them to explore areas of the store they may not usually visit.

The longer customers spend in a store the more money they are likely to spend there. Therefore stores work to make sure customers have to spend the maximum amount of time in their stores, placing obstacles constantly in the way of efficient shopping.

Newer areas where a lot more research is needed

In the UK, the British buy almost two-thirds of their wine from supermarkets; and more than a third of all wines sold in America are purchased at grocery stores, even though only 33 of the 50 US states allow supermarkets to sell wine. Wine is now the largest supermarket category in New Zealand and supermarket sales represent around 60 per cent of total wine sales.

As with any product promotion, there is no 'one solution' for supermarket wine departments. Unlike staples such as milk or eggs, wine is a luxury item (although many will beg to differ). This is the first hurdle for retailers. The difficulty of overcoming this hurdle varies from region to region. Additionally, retailers must decide how much effort and expense to invest in this part of their store. Decisions on these matters must also take into account the local competition, be it a wholesaler or a new chic wine boutique. First and foremost, know your customers.

At the end of the day, basic marketing principles will sell more wine than the most experienced supermarket wine steward. The longer customers stay in the wine department, the more likely they are to make a purchase. That can be encouraged by a tasting, music, or warm lighting. One Piggly Wiggly supermarket in Wisconsin features an expansive wine and spirits department that replicates a speciality wine cellar complete with wood shelving with a library ladder and an extensive walk-in cooler. Music can help in more specialist sales settings. Research at Leicester University showed that French music played in a supermarket's wine aisle boosted sales of French wines. The following day, German folk music led to German wines flying off the shelves.

Here, as in Website optimization, there's no substitute for subject matter expertise!

Friday, February 27, 2009

Website Optimization & Analytics

.


Your Web site, some ways people access it, and a couple of .......... tools you can use to optimize its performance.

For a long time, the only solution to make websites appealing and "sticky" was to rely on gurus (web designers who were just supposed to know the "right" answers). But what if the guru made a mistake or did not take into account all the variables and created less-than-optimal pages? The potential loss of not optimizing a landing page may be staggering.

You want to deploy Web pages that fulfill a business purpose. Your goal might be selling your product (at a profit!), distributing information (such as newly legislated prerequisites for obtaining a driver license), gathering information (such as the demographics of potential customers) from an on-line form that doesn't turn people away because it's too complicated or intrusive, etc.

The question is what do you put on your page(s) to achieve your goal(s)? You could decide on your own or together with a team of in-house experts and hope for the best. Or you could throw the process of Website design open to the world of users beyond your firewall. In doing so, you would be democratizing the process by letting the public tell you, through their actual behavior, which of a number of possible designs gets them to use your Web page(s) in the way that you had hoped they would. As pointed out in a fairly recent New York Times article, the latter approach has now become main stream.

I've chosen Google Website Optimizer (GWO) - in part because it's free - to try different layouts, alternate content, new buttons, and even new colors through multivariate testing and split A/B testing without making permanent changes to my site. Better yet, my visitors themselves ultimately determine which combination of site elements cause them to perform the actions I desire such as filling out a form, adding an item to the shopping cart, or taking the big plunge to enter their credit card.



The Combination Report of Website Optimizer

A combination report will show the performance results for all of the page combinations made from the page section variations you created for your experiment. By seeing how well a particular combination performs in comparison with the original and the other combinations, you can choose the most successful one to improve your business.

GWO's intuitive reports (like the combination report shown above) allow even the mathematically-challenged to quickly and easily identify and implement the best combination. My article Statistical and Financial Considerations in Website Optimization is aimed at those who want to go beyond the, albeit powerful, analyses that are possible using GWO alone. In this article, I export raw data from the Combination Report and discuss using an offline statistical analysis on it, as outlined in the block diagram at the top of this post.

Click on the images above to see larger views.





Hover your cursor over a video to gain play-pause and forward-back